Klondike vs Spider Solitaire: Which One is Right for You?

Solitaire is one of the most beloved card games in the world, and among its many variations, Klondike and Spider Solitaire stand out as the most popular; but which one should you play? Whether you're a casual player looking for fun or a competitive player aiming to improve your skills, understanding the differences between these two games will help you decide.

In this article, we'll compare Klondike and Spider Solitaire, discussing their difficulty levels, strategies, and player preferences. Plus, we've included a quiz at the end to help you determine which game suits you best!

Understanding the Basics

Before diving into a comparison, let's briefly review how each game is played.

What is Klondike Solitaire?

Klondike is the classic version of solitaire that most people recognize. It's the default solitaire game on Windows computers and is often simply referred to as “Solitaire” or sometimes “Patience” in the UK.

• Deck: 52-card standard deck
• Objective: Move all cards to the four foundation piles in ascending order, starting from Ace and ending with King, all of the same suit.
• Gameplay:
  • Cards are arranged in seven tableau columns.
  • You can move alternating-color sequences.
  • The stock allows you to draw one or three cards at a time, depending on the variation.
  • Empty spaces can be filled with a King or a packed sequence of cards headed by a King.

Play Klondike Solitaire online

What is Spider Solitaire?

Spider Solitaire is a more challenging variation of solitaire that requires two decks of cards (104 cards total) and a unique approach to sequencing.

There are two easier variations of Spider called Spider One Suit and Spider Two Suits. Spider One Suit uses all the Spades from eight decks of cards making 104 cards total. This makes the game considerably easier. Spider Two Suits uses the Spades and Hearts from four decks of cards making 104 cards total. This is a harder version than One Suit but not as difficult as Spider that uses all four suits.

• Deck: Two 52-card decks (104 cards total)
• Objective: Build complete sequences of cards in descending order (King to Ace) of the same suit within the tableau.
• Gameplay:
  • 10 tableau columns with varying numbers of face-down and face-up cards.
  • You can move single exposed cards or descending sequences of the same suit.
  • When no moves are available, you can deal additional cards from the stock but there can't be any empty columns.

Try Spider Solitaire here

Comparing Klondike and Spider Solitaire

Now, let's break down the key differences between these two games and which one might be a better fit for you.

1. Difficulty Level

Feature	Klondike Solitaire	Spider Solitaire
Number of Decks	1 deck (52 cards)	2 decks (104 cards)
Winning Probability	Moderate	Low
Skill Level Required	Beginner to intermediate	Advanced
Time Commitment	Shorter games (5-10 minutes)	Longer games (15-30 minutes)

Klondike is generally easier and more accessible for beginners, while Spider Solitaire offers a deeper challenge with a lower win probability.

2. Strategy Differences

Klondike Strategies:

• Click on the deck at the start of the game to deal a card(s) before making any other moves. It increases the initial number of possible moves and gives you the opportunity to make a better choice.
• Move aces and twos to the foundations immediately.
• Prioritize uncovering face-down cards as this might reveal an important card that can make a difference in your game.
• If you have a choice of moves that expose face-down cards then choose the column that contains the most face-down cards.
• Build foundations piles evenly. Don't let one of the foundation piles build up much higher than the other foundation piles as this creates an imbalance in the rest of the cards, which can block your columns.
• Don't create an empty space unless a King is available to play on it as you'll be reducing the number of columns you can build cards on. You can always wait and make that move if a King becomes available.

Spider Strategies:

• Make sure all moves on the tableau have been exhausted before you click on the stock to deal more cards.
• Prioritize creating empty columns. They can be filled by any card rank and this allows you to re-arrange the tableau and free up cards that are stuck.
• Create the longest descending same suit sequence as possible even if it means breaking up another packed column. This maximizes your chances of creating a King to Ace sequence that will be transferred to the foundations.
• Try to build descending sequences of the same suit rather than creating mixed-suit sequences otherwise it gets very difficult to progress.

3. Player Preferences: Who Should Play Which Game?

Choose Klondike Solitaire if:

• You enjoy a mix of strategy and luck.
• You prefer shorter, casual games.
• You are new to solitaire and want an easier introduction.

Choose Spider Solitaire if:

• You like a challenging puzzle-solving experience.
• You prefer games that require more long-term strategy.
• You want a higher level of difficulty with lower win rates.

Quiz: Which Solitaire Game is Right for You?

Take this quick quiz to find out which solitaire variation best suits your playstyle!

1. How much time do you typically want to spend on a game?

• A) 5-10 minutes → Klondike
• B) 15-30 minutes → Spider

2. Do you prefer a game with a higher chance of winning?

• A) Yes, I like frequent wins → Klondike
• B) No, I enjoy a challenge → Spider

3. Do you like working with multiple decks at once?

• A) No, I prefer a simpler game → Klondike
• B) Yes, I like the challenge → Spider

4. Do you enjoy methodical planning over a longer period?

• A) Not really, I prefer quick decisions → Klondike
• B) Yes, I like planning many moves ahead → Spider

5. Are you looking for a relaxing game or a challenging one?

• A) Relaxing → Klondike
• B) Challenging → Spider

Results

• Mostly A's - You'll likely enjoy Klondike Solitaire more.
• Mostly B's - You're better suited for Spider Solitaire!

Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?

Both Klondike and Spider Solitaire have their unique appeals, and the best choice depends on your personal preferences. If you're looking for a relaxing, casual experience, Klondike is the way to go. However, if you want a more challenging and strategic game, Spider Solitaire will keep you engaged.

Still undecided? Try playing both at Free Play Solitaire and see which one you enjoy the most!

iPhone / iPad Solitaire | Android Solitaire | Kindle Fire Solitaire | Windows Solitaire